If you've lived anywhere near Winter Park for more than a hot minute, you've almost certainly wandered into Miller's Hardware on Fairbanks Avenue. Maybe you needed a single bolt. Maybe a screen-door spring nobody on the planet still stocked. Maybe you just wanted somebody to look at the busted thing in your hand and tell you, plainly, what on earth it was called. For more than 80 years, that's exactly what this place did. Now, after four generations of the Miller family, the doors are about to swing shut for the last time.
The shop sits at 143 W. Fairbanks Avenue, a short stroll from the boutiques of Park Avenue. Until April 2026, it held the title of the city's oldest continuously operated family-owned business. Its story is part Greatest Generation grit, part small-town Florida charm, and, toward the end, a quiet family heartbreak that no big-box competitor or hurricane ever managed to deliver.
For anyone who's recently put down roots in greater Orlando, the Miller's Hardware story is worth knowing. Winter Park doesn't always advertise its own history loudly, but a building like this is a quiet landmark, the kind of place locals point to when they want to explain why this little city feels different from the rest of Central Florida's master-planned sprawl.
Table of Contents
From a Five-and-Dime to a Winter Park Institution
Long before the lumber aisles and the paint mixers, there were nickels and dimes. In 1940, Robert R. Miller showed up in Winter Park hunting for a business that was, in his own words, "recession proof". He'd watched the Great Depression chew through American Main Streets, and his answer was small, practical, and stubbornly steady: a Ben Franklin Five and Dime, parked directly across from the old Colony Theater on Park Avenue.
Four years later, in 1944, Miller sold the Five and Dime and bought a modest 50-by-50-foot building on Fairbanks Avenue, then a sleepy two-lane road shaded by trees. In 1945, he reopened the space as a paint and hardware shop with about 800 square feet of selling floor and a tagline that was a little ahead of its time: "The Woman's Hardware since 1945." Winter Park, back then, was a town of barely 5,000 people. The pace of life was slow enough that buying a hammer counted as an outing.
That tiny storefront is the seed of everything Miller's Hardware would become.
Four Generations Behind the Counter
Robert R. Miller ran the shop until his death in 1962. His son, Robert "Bob" A. Miller, took over alongside business partner Cliff Canada, and the two of them rode the wave of Central Florida's 1960s and '70s growth, a boom that pulled in Walt Disney World, Interstate 4, and a whole new suburban Orange County. In 1984, Canada sold his share back to Bob, returning the store to full family ownership.
Bob then pulled his son Steve, a CPA by training, off his calculator and onto the sales floor. By the mid-1990s, Steve was running the place as the third-generation owner, and the footprint kept growing. The original 800-square-foot paint shop eventually sprawled to roughly 17,000 square feet on nearly an acre of land, carrying more than 67,000 items through the Do it Best cooperative. We're talking tools, grills, fireplaces, housewares, gardening supplies, and aisle after glorious aisle of hardware most people didn't know they needed until they needed it at 7 a.m. on a Saturday.
Steve's three kids, Stevie, Clay, and Krista, all worked the floor at various points. That's the fourth generation, and it's where the long arc of the family story gets complicated. By that point, Miller's Hardware wasn't just a store; it was a small economic engine for the family, employing relatives, longtime managers, and dozens of part-timers over the years.
The "Third Place" Where Winter Park Ran Into Itself
Sociologists have a phrase for spots like this: "third places," the spaces that aren't home and aren't work, where a town casually keeps tabs on itself. Coffee shops do it. Barbershops do it. And in Winter Park, the hardware store on Fairbanks did it about as well as anywhere.
Regulars came in for decades. Then their kids came in. Then their kids' kids started showing up too, presumably asking the same question about the same broken lamp. In a 2013 interview, Steve Miller put it like this: "We have second-generation and even third-generation people shopping here. Somebody will say, 'Yeah, I remember my dad coming in here shopping.'"
That kind of continuity is genuinely rare. Most American retail measures lifespans in fashion cycles. Miller's Hardware measured them in family trees. Walk in on any given Saturday morning over the last 30 years and you'd hear the same low hum: somebody's grandkid asking about a wrench size, a contractor leaning on the counter telling a story, and Steve or one of the family pointing without looking at exactly which aisle held the thing you came in for.
Hurricane Charley and the Test of a Hometown Store
If you want to know what an independent hardware store is actually for, look at August 2004. Hurricane Charley carved a destructive path across Central Florida, knocking out power for days and leaving entire neighborhoods scrambling for basics.
The Miller family had stocked up in advance, batteries, flashlights, generators, propane, the whole disaster bingo card, and they threw the doors open. The line of customers reportedly stretched out of the building and down Fairbanks Avenue. It wasn't a price-gouging moment or a publicity stunt. It was a neighborhood store doing what neighborhood stores are supposed to do when the lights go out. In a region that had grown comfortable with Walmart parking lots and Lowe's pickup lines, Miller's Hardware reminded people what a locally owned shop can actually pull off on short notice.
Nine years later, in September 2013, the Winter Park City Commission handed Miller's Hardware its Third Quarter Business Recognition Award. Then-mayor Ken Bradley called the family "community builders," people who weren't just chasing margins but were trying to make the city a little nicer while they did it. In 2024, the shop also picked up a Service Award from Angi.
The Loss That Reshaped the Future
By the mid-2010s, Steve's son Clay Miller was stepping into a serious role at the store. Clay was the planned fourth-generation owner, described by family and coworkers as enthusiastic, ambitious, and ready to grow the "Miller's Brand." The family even opened a second location for the first time in the store's history. For a hot minute, Miller's Hardware looked like it might become a small Central Florida chain.
Then, on September 30, 2019, Clay Miller died unexpectedly at the age of 29. The grief rippled through the Winter Park business community. Fellow hardware operators, including Toole's Ace Hardware, publicly mourned. The second store quietly closed not long after. Steve kept running the Fairbanks location, but the long-term succession plan, the thing that had carried the family across eight decades, was broken in a way nothing could quite repair.
The Final Chapter on Fairbanks Avenue
In early April 2026, the family confirmed the news: Miller's Hardware was closing for good. A liquidation sale started on April 9, and everything became fair game, inventory, shelving, store displays, the whole works. Bob Canfield, who'd worked at the shop for nearly 20 years, said he planned to stay through the final day. That's the kind of loyalty you can't poach with a signing bonus.
No exact closing date was locked in at the announcement, but local reporting pointed toward late May 2026 as the likely end. The roughly 13,000-square-foot building sits on nearly an acre, a stone's throw from the upscale Park Avenue corridor, and as you might imagine, developers started circling almost immediately, like seagulls over a forgotten french fry. As of mid-April, no sale had been finalized. Whatever rises on the Miller's Hardware site next, it will almost certainly look nothing like what stood there for the last eight decades.
What Miller's Hardware Meant to the Neighborhood
If you've only recently moved to greater Orlando, it's easy to underestimate what's actually being lost here. This isn't a chain shutting a single underperforming location. Miller's Hardware predates Walt Disney World. It predates Interstate 4. It opened back when Winter Park was a town of 5,000 people and Fairbanks Avenue was a tree-lined two-lane road. The shop survived the death of the five-and-dime, the rise and dominance of big-box chains, the arrival of internet retail, and a direct hit from a major hurricane. What it could not survive was the loss of the kid who was supposed to inherit it.
Independent hardware stores across the country are quietly disappearing for far more boring reasons: margins, rents, online competition, generational fatigue. The Winter Park story is different. This was a business that had every reason to keep going and every customer base to support it. It's closing because of a hole in the family that no business model can paper over.
If You're New to the Area, Here's the Takeaway
Winter Park is a small city with a long memory. Places like Miller's Hardware are how that memory gets stored, not in plaques or museum displays, but in the casual habit of bumping into your neighbor in the lightbulb aisle. If you're new to greater Orlando and trying to figure out what makes this particular corner of Central Florida feel different from, say, Lake Nona or Dr. Phillips, the answer lives largely in places like this one.
The shop's final weeks are worth a visit, even if you don't need a single thing. Walk the aisles. Run your hand across the worn-smooth wooden bins. Say hello to Bob Canfield if he's around. You won't get another chance to stand inside Miller's Hardware in the heart of Winter Park, and whatever pops up on that lot next will tell a very different story about what this city is becoming.
Miller's Hardware is closing. The corner stays. The neighborhood will figure out the rest the way it always has, together, usually with somebody holding a paint stir stick.
🔥 Love Orlando history like this? Well, there's plenty more where this came from, right here.
Sources:
https://winterparklibraryarchives.org/exhibits/show/histbisref/miller-s-hardware
https://www.doitbest.com/millers-hardware-winter-park/
https://www.orangeobserver.com/news/2013/oct/02/after-68-years-millers-still-all-family/
https://www.thestreet.com/retail/80-year-old-millers-hardware-closes-store-no-bankruptcy
https://www.legacy.com/obituaries/name/clayton-miller-obituary?pid=194114386
https://orlandoshine.com/winter-parks-oldest-family-business-is-closing-after-more-than-80-years/
https://www.fox35orlando.com/news/millers-hardware-winter-park-store-closing-after-80-years-family-sells-property
https://www.wftv.com/news/local/millers-hardware-winter-park-shut-down-after-more-than-80-years/KVQ54NUXXNCKRBEHNU6Q54ESJ4/
